The Best Luxury Consignment Stores in New York
Renowned for its trendsetting culture and unmatched luxury shopping experiences, New York is a heaven for fashion enthusiasts. But while most fashion lovers flock to Fifth Avenue or one of the city’s iconic department stores (which is also a must when visiting the city!), true connoisseurs start their shopping journeys at the city’s best consignment stores.
From small, family establishments on the Upper East Side to opulent Flagship locations in SoHo, New York City is brimming with luxury consignment stores. However, out of all of those places, a select few stand out. And today I would like to introduce you to those. So, grab yourself a cup of coffee (or something else) and keep scrolling to discover the 5 best luxury consignment stores in NYC!
1. Michael’s Luxury Consignment
Address: 1125 Madison Avenue at 84th Street New York, NY 10028
Starting up with one of the oldest (if not the oldest) luxury consignment store in NYC: Michael’s Luxury Consignment. A family-owned business founded in 1954, the store offers its clients a meticulously curated selection of authenticated designer clothing and accessories. Whether you are purchasing or consigning, Michael’s personal and hands-on approach will make you feel like at home. Not even to mention that their store is absolutely stunning.
2. Designer Revival
Address: 324 East 81st Street New York, NY 10028
A neighborhood mainstay for over 30 years, Designer Revival is another NYC-based consignment store worth your attention. Often referred to as “a NYC trendsetter’s best kept secret”, the store delights with a meticulously curated collection of 100% authentic designer pieces and personalized service. At Designer Revival, you will find anything from pre-loved designer and vintage to contemporary clothing, shoes and accessories. All pieces are also competitively priced, so that everyone gets a chance to own something beautiful.
3. TheRealReal
Addresses: 80 Wooster St, New York, NY 10012 (Flagship location);
870 Madison Ave, New York, NY 10028;
163 Court St, Brooklyn, NY 11201.
Moving on to more of the mainstream names, or specifically, TheRealReal. Founded in 2011 with an ambitious goal which was to extend the life cycle of luxury goods and create a more sustainable future for fashion, TheRealReal has grown to become one of the largest luxury consignment stores in the U.S., with both online and physical presence around the country, incl. three stores in the New York City (the Flagship location in SoHo and two smaller stores in the Upper East Side and Brooklyn). Visit TheRealReal to experience a curated selection of pre-loved luxury goods firsthand. Among those, designer clothing, handbags, fine jewelry and other accessories.
4. Fashionphile
Address: 601 W 26th St STE 400B Floor 4, New York, NY 10001
If you love luxury handbags as much as I do, then you also want to visit Fashionphile’s NYC Flagship. Featuring an extensive range of pre-loved designer bags from brands like Hermès, Louis Vuitton, and Dior, it is a paradise for any handbag enthusiast. Though the real draw is the store’s impressive warehouse, affectionately dubbed “the Cage,” which showcases walls upon walls of these coveted, color-coordinated pre-loved finds – including the famous Birkin aisle. Tempted to plan a visit yet?
5. What Goes Around Comes Around (WGACA)
Address: 351 W Broadway, New York, NY 10013, United States
Wrapping up my list of the best luxury consignment stores in NYC with What Goes Around Comes Around, also known as WGACA. Founded in in 1993 by Seth Weisser and Gerard Maione, What Goes Around Comes Around is the premier purveyor of the finest luxury vintage accessories and clothing. For over 30 years, WGACA has elevated traditional vintage shopping into a high-fashion experience. And quite frankly, their store on 351 W Broadway really feels more like a museum than a shop, with carefully displayed vintage treasures lining the walls.
Which one of these stores would you visit first? Let’s chat in the comments below!
xoxo’s, Masha S.
